When Meghan Markle admitted during her 2019 tour of South Africa that she was not doing well, the moment immediately attracted attention. Standing beside Prince Harry, with a young Archie still a baby, she appeared close to tears as journalist Tom Bradby asked a question that seemed to catch her off guard: was she really okay? Her answer was brief, but it revealed more than the carefully composed royal appearances had suggested.

At the time, much of the discussion centered on the pressures of joining the Royal Family, the expectations placed on her as a new duchess and the demands of motherhood. Meghan herself referred to the difficulties of being pregnant, becoming a mother and adjusting to life under intense public scrutiny. Those pressures were clearly part of the picture, but there is another detail worth revisiting: by the time she arrived in South Africa, Meghan had also been dealing with a painful and increasingly complicated situation involving her father, Thomas Markle.

Could that family turmoil have added another layer to what she was experiencing? It is a question that deserves attention, particularly when her later account to Oprah Winfrey is considered alongside what was known about the relationship with her father at the time.

The question in South Africa opened a door

The famous exchange took place during the Sussexes’ 2019 African tour, when Bradby asked Meghan how she was coping with the attention surrounding her new life. She explained that pregnancy and having a newborn had made an already challenging period more difficult, before adding that not many people had asked whether she was okay.

When Bradby suggested that she was not really okay and that it had been a struggle, Meghan agreed.

The response was striking because the couple had spent much of the tour carrying out official engagements, smiling for photographs and presenting a picture of a young family embracing an important royal visit. Yet behind those public appearances, Meghan was acknowledging that she was struggling.

It would be tempting to attribute everything to royal protocol, the demands of the tour and the scrutiny that followed her almost everywhere. However, there was also the situation with her father, which had been unfolding for more than a year and had become a very public source of distress.

Play

The painful situation with her father was already unfolding

Meghan’s relationship with Thomas Markle had deteriorated before her wedding to Prince Harry in May 2018. His staged paparazzi photographs, his interviews with the media and his absence from the wedding created a family situation that continued to attract headlines long after the couple had married.

There was also a deeply personal correspondence between father and daughter. According to court documents, Meghan sent Thomas a five-page private letter on August 27, 2018. Its contents became public in February 2019 after he provided it to the Mail on Sunday, prompting a legal battle over the publication of her private correspondence.

But another, separate letter is particularly important to this discussion. In October 2026, Meghan revealed that she had received information about disturbing allegations concerning her father in a letter originally sent to the Metropolitan Police and Royalty and Specialist Protection. She said she had been assured that the allegations were being investigated.

The Metropolitan Police subsequently confirmed that it had received the letter in January 2019 and forwarded it to Harry and Meghan’s office. Meghan’s spokesperson acknowledged that she may have been mistaken about the date when she said it was sent in 2018, accepting the police record as accurate.

That means the information had reached the couple before the South Africa tour in September and October 2019. It is a significant piece of background that was not part of the public conversation when Meghan spoke to Bradby.

It does not establish that the letter was responsible for her distress, but it does raise a question about how much she was dealing with privately while continuing to appear in public.

What Meghan later told Oprah revealed the depth of her struggle

When Meghan and Harry sat down with Oprah Winfrey in March 2021, the South Africa interview came up again. Oprah specifically asked why Bradby’s simple question about whether she was okay had struck such a nerve.

Meghan explained that it was the final day of the tour and that she was exhausted. She said the couple had been making everything look fine because they were doing their jobs, even though she had been suffering for a considerable time and had been asking the institution for help.

She also described how her difficulties had begun much earlier, after the couple returned from their Australia tour, and spoke about the period during her pregnancy when she began to understand what her future within the Royal Family might look like.

Her most serious revelation concerned her mental health. Meghan told Oprah that she had experienced suicidal thoughts, describing them as frightening and persistent. She said she had approached senior people within the institution because she needed help and had even asked to go somewhere to receive professional care. According to her account, she was told that doing so would not be good for the institution.

Harry also described how frightened he had been when Meghan told him what she was experiencing. He said he had not known what to do and had wanted to be there for his wife.

These were deeply serious disclosures, and Meghan was clear about the experiences she was describing. She did not, however, identify her father’s situation as the cause of her suicidal thoughts or suggest that the letter about him was the reason she had struggled.

Was there more to her pain than the public understood?

That is what makes the South Africa moment worth examining again. Meghan was navigating a difficult relationship with her father, the public fallout from their estrangement, the demands of motherhood and the pressure of representing the monarchy while facing relentless media attention.

The information about the letter concerning Thomas Markle adds another part of that timeline, although the exact effect it had on Meghan personally remains unknown. It would be unfair to claim that it explains her mental health struggles when she herself described a much wider combination of pressures.

Still, the question remains: when Meghan told Tom Bradby that she was not okay, how much of what she was carrying had the public actually seen? The world was watching a new royal mother struggling to adjust to an extraordinary life, but there may have been private family worries adding to an already painful period.

Her later conversation with Oprah gave the public a far more serious understanding of what she said she had endured. Whether the situation with her father made those days even harder is something Meghan has not publicly established. What is clear is that the smile seen during the South Africa tour did not tell the whole story.