Just as Meghan Markle may have thought that the already deeply embarrassing and humbling situation with her estranged father could not possibly get any worse, another very personal detail has just come to light from Thomas Markle’s court-ordered psychiatric report. In the course of speaking to a psychiatrist about his family, Thomas reportedly mixed up Meghan with her half-sister Samantha and stated that he only had one daughter.
It is a painful detail, given that Meghan and her father have been estranged for years, with their relationship falling apart at the time of her 2018 wedding to Prince Harry. Some believe the comments clearly relate to Thomas’s reported memory issues rather than being a calculated attempt to alienate Meghan. However, the way they’re worded is still hard to take, particularly as the Duchess is already facing troubling allegations against him.
Thomas Appeared to Confuse Meghan With Samantha
According to a psychiatric report discussed by Us Weekly, Thomas was asked about his children during an examination conducted as part of the legal proceedings against him.
He initially identified his son, Thomas Markle Jr., and his daughter Meghan, even mentioning that the psychiatrist might have heard of her.
But when the doctor asked about a second daughter, Samantha, Thomas reportedly became confused.
“I don’t think so. I have two kids. I think Meghan is Samantha; I only have one daughter and one son,” he said, according to the report.
The psychiatrist also recorded that Thomas referred to Meghan as his sister at another point during the conversation before apologizing for the mistake.
It is not hard to see why this latest bit of information would be so upsetting for Meghan. Her relationship with her dad has been severed for years, and now, with his legal issues having resurrected their family history in the press, the report from his own medical report is another very painful piece of the puzzle.
Still, the comments have to be understood in context. The psychiatrist was assessing Thomas, and the report did raise concerns about his memory and his cognitive health. There is no suggestion that he made those comments with any intention of harming his daughter.
The Court Has Now Ruled Thomas Competent to Stand Trial
The report came as Thomas was in the midst of a significant development in his federal case in Florida.
On 19th November, a judge ruled that the 82-year-old was mentally fit to stand trial on a charge of possessing child sexual abuse material. That came after an independent psychiatric report, in which the court accepted the psychiatrist’s finding that Thomas was mentally capable of understanding the proceedings and assisting in his own defense.
The psychiatrist did identify a significant neurocognitive disorder (potentially related to vascular disease) but also concluded that Thomas was capable of taking part in the legal process. He thought Thomas might have overestimated his memory problems when questioned about the allegations.
The case itself is extremely serious. Federal prosecutors allege that investigators discovered suspected child sexual abuse material in two Los Angeles-area storage units rented by Thomas. According to the FBI affidavit, some of the material included photographs allegedly depicting Thomas with underage girls.
Thomas has denied the allegations entirely, calling them lies. He has not been convicted, and the matter will be decided in court. His next preliminary hearing is set for December 1st.
Meghan Has Already Explained Why She Walked Away
For Meghan, this is not just about a father she is estranged from reappearing in the news. She has previously made it clear that her decision to keep her distance from Thomas, and to keep him away from Archie and Lilibet, was to protect her children.
Following the allegations coming to light, the Duchess said in a statement that she was very upset and was thinking of any children who might have been affected. She also said a letter had been sent to UK authorities in 2018 regarding her father, and that she had been told it was being looked into.
She said the distance between them was not something she took lightly; it was a decision she felt was necessary for her family.
As Thomas faces the prospect of a criminal trial, Meghan is once again being drawn into a family story she’s spent decades trying to escape.
The latest comments may not have been intended as an insult, particularly given the concerns about his mental health and alleged memory loss. Still, they are another reminder of just how fractured this relationship has become.
There was a time when Thomas was preparing to walk his daughter down the aisle at Windsor Castle. He never made it to the wedding, and their relationship never recovered.
Now that Meghan is building a life with Harry and the kids in the UK, and her dad is facing serious criminal allegations in the US, the distance between them seems even greater than before. There doesn’t appear to be any answer, from either side, on whether anything can be mended at this stage.





Comments